Frequently Asked Questions

We primarily sell seasonal and every day decorated butter cookies, and we also have gingerbread cookies–usually October through March. See our product page for more information about our delicious cookies.
We primarily sell three sizes of hand cut cookies:

  • Regular–2 ounces–our bestseller by far
  • Small–1 to 1.5 ounces
  • Bites–1/3 ounce

You can select from three categories of cookies:

  • Holiday–includes all major holidays plus a few other special days
  • Special Occasions–includes birthdays, graduations, weddings, showers, anniversaries
  • Every Day–includes get well, thank you, thinking of you

We also have custom and private label options to accommodate your logo and special colors.

Yes. None of our products use ingredients that contain nuts or peanuts, and we avoid cross-contamination because we do not allow nuts or peanuts in our production facility.

Our products are recommended by several Nut and Peanut free sites, including

Please note that the nut and peanut free claim does not apply to bulk cookies unless your facility is also nut and peanut free.

We use no preservatives in our cookies, but we do use a high-quality cellophane bag with a barrier so individually wrapped cookies have a shelf life of six months. Retailers can usually anticipate a sell-through rate of three to four weeks.
Our standard packaging includes:

  • Clear cellophane individual or multi-cookie bags tied with nylon tulle
  • Gift boxes and tins, typically with bite-sized cookies
  • Bulk cookies unwrapped

We also do private label and custom baking and packaging.

Yes. Our customers can choose a single UPC code across all cookies for pricing accuracy at checkout or individual UPCs. (Most regular 2-ounce cookies have the same price.) We can even add your pricing to individual UPC code labels.
Cases of 72 are the most economical order quantity, although we do support lower quantities.

Bulk cookies are available by the pallet with a minimum of 30 mixed cases.

We have three product groups: holiday, special occasions and everyday. You can select your own mix of designs or tell us the group(s) you want and we’ll send you our best sellers.

We offer stores more than 20 buying opportunities throughout the year. Experience demonstrates that stores that keep a varying stock year-round perform much better during the holidays due to the loyal following they have created.

Contact us for more information or to place an order.

We recommend that you carry our regular 2-ounce butter cookies that are individually wrapped and tied with nylon tulle. The attractive individual packaging makes them easy to grab and give or just slip into to a shopping basket to take-away for an afternoon treat.

Sticking with our bestsellers and carrying our cookies year-round typically results in the best sell-through.

Most in-house bakeries select our regular 2-ounce cookies since that preserves their nut free status, and they provide more display options, including at checkout. If your preferred display is in a bakery case, then bulk is also an option to get to a lower price point.

Customers that have the most success with our cookies during traditional holiday buying seasons have one thing in common. They carry our cookies year round. Our changing array of designs creates more than 20 buying opportunities throughout the year.

We have a long history of being a top seller through this channel and work with a wide range of food gift, monthly subscription, floral or other special occasion gift-giving retailers.

O’ My Goodness’ hand-decorated cookies have starred for many years as beautiful accent pieces for gift baskets, tins and boxes. Food gift packers also have had success with our cookies in holiday or special occasion assortments.

We will work with you to create a unique gift box at the price point you need. See our Gift Page for more details.

We typically ship in one or two weeks. Pallet orders ship in four weeks or less. We also try to maintain some inventory of top sellers for same day shipping of individual cases.
We ship to distribution centers via LTL common carriers or store direct via FedEx. We can also ship via UPS with your account number.
Yes. We are EDI enabled.
O’ My Goodness is annually certified by AIB. Copies of the GMC certification report as well as our HAACP and other documentation to support your vendor management programs are available upon request.

Didn’t find your answer? Just ask!